The plaintiff Lorraine Sinkler (Sinkler) commenced this action against the defendant Emma Goldsmith (Emma) to obtain a declaratory judgment “declaring the. Lorraine Sinkler is the author of The Spiritual Journey of Joel S. Goldsmith ( avg rating, 21 ratings, 0 reviews, published ), The Alchemy of Awa. Lorraine Sinkler has 40 books on Goodreads with ratings. Lorraine Sinkler’s most popular book is Practicing the Presence: The Inspirational Guide to.

Author: Shaktinos Mebar
Country: Zimbabwe
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Career
Published (Last): 3 February 2011
Pages: 104
PDF File Size: 6.37 Mb
ePub File Size: 18.28 Mb
ISBN: 860-9-91303-766-4
Downloads: 41915
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Gokinos

Joint Work Sinkler’s fourth cause of action alleges that Horizons of Consciousness is a joint work of Sinkler sinkper Joel.

The Gift of Love by Joel S. English Choose a language for shopping.

Therefore, the issue of whether Emma was mentally competent at the time that the copyright of Joel’s letters was registered is not relevant. The Spiritual Journey of Joel S. Consciousness Unfolding by Joel S.

Nothing in the note or the letter suggests an intent on Joel’s part to abandon whatever rights he may have had in his letters. Lorraine Sinkler was born in in Minot, North Dakota.

Sinkler v. Goldsmith, F. Supp. (D. Ariz. ) :: Justia

Are you an author? He was especially delighted when Lorraine began accepting invitations from around the country to give classes of her own.


She worked with Joel closely both as a student of The Infinite Way and later as editor of most of his work. AmazonGlobal Ship Orders Internationally.

The Valor Foundation

Beyond Words and Thoughts by Joel S. Sinkler denies that Emma has a copyright in Joel’s letters because 1 he abandoned any such interest by the September 29,note and the January 27,letter to Sinkler, 2 he never owned a copyright interest in the letters, and 3 Emma was incompetent at the time of the registration of the copyright.

The only evidence in the record that Emma granted Sinkler oral permission to publish Joel’s private letters is Sinkler’s testimony. GoldsmithLorraine Sinkler 4. Goldsmith that he sent to plaintiff. Sinkler has been lecturing on “The Infinite Way” for over 20 years. Amazon Second Chance Pass it on, trade it in, give it a second life.

Sinkler’s second cause of action alleges that Emma gave her a license to publish Joel’s letters in writing and lorrsine. A Parenthesis in Eternity by Joel S.

Emma claims that she has been damaged by Sinkler’s failure to assemble the annual books. Whatever copyright Emma had in those letters must be deemed to have been abandoned.

The Valor Foundation – Biography of Lorraine Sinkler

There is no evidence that Joel, either expressly or by performance or dissemination, released his letters for public consumption. The Altitude of Prayer by Joel S. By a letter dated September 15,Emma informed Sinkler that she was terminating the contract.


The offices of The Infinite Way were established by Joel and Emma in Hawaii in about and were primarily supervised by Joel until his death in She contends that she discontinued assembling the Letters into books at that time because the publisher informed her that there was no market for the books.

The Alchemy of Awareness. There is no showing that Joel exploited the use of his name and personality by lordaine the right to use them to another. Rate this book Clear rating 1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars.

The first time that she ever contended that Sinkler was engaging in unfair competition by using “The Infinite Way” was in connection with this action. You will know when the time is right. United States District Court, D. Emma has been aware of these lectures. Sihkler, who is not a lawyer, was aware of this principle before this action was commenced.

Refresh and try again. Authorship was to be attributed to Joel. District Court for the District of Arizona – F.